Skip to content

Garden projects

Timber vs composite decking

Softwood, hardwood or composite? How to choose the right decking for a Scottish garden, with honest pros and cons for each.

11 November 2026

A deck is one of the best ways to turn an uneven or sloping garden into usable, level space. The first big decision is the material: timber or composite. Both can make a beautiful deck, but they age very differently and suit different owners.

Here's how the three main options, softwood timber, hardwood timber and composite, stack up for a Scottish garden.

The three options in brief

  • Softwood timber (usually pressure-treated pine) is the most affordable and the most common decking in the UK.
  • Hardwood timber (such as balau or iroko) is denser, richer in colour and longer-lasting, at a higher price.
  • Composite is a manufactured blend of wood fibres and plastic, sold in boards that need no staining and resist rot.

Appearance

  • Softwood has a warm, natural grain that looks lovely fresh-laid. Over the years it fades to a soft grey unless you treat it.
  • Hardwood is striking, with tight grain and rich tones. It ages gracefully and holds its character for decades.
  • Composite is uniform and consistent, which some people love and others find a little too "manufactured". It comes in a range of colours that won't fade as dramatically as timber.

Maintenance

This is where the materials really diverge.

  • Timber (softwood especially) wants a yearly clean and a fresh coat of stain or oil every year or two to keep its colour and protect the surface. Skip it and the boards will silver, then eventually crack and splinter.
  • Hardwood needs less frequent treatment but still benefits from an oil now and then to keep its colour.
  • Composite needs only an occasional wash with soapy water. No staining, no oiling, no sanding. For anyone who wants a deck they can enjoy rather than maintain, this is the big draw.

Longevity

A well-built timber deck will give you a good number of years of service, and a hardwood deck considerably more. The frame and fixings matter as much as the boards: a deck rots from the underside up, so proper joists, drainage and airflow underneath are essential in our damp climate.

Composite boards themselves won't rot, and good ranges carry long warranties. Their lifespan is usually limited by the subframe beneath them, which is why we always build composite decks on a properly treated timber or metal frame rather than assuming the boards will outlast everything.

Slip and the Scottish weather

  • Timber can get slippery as algae builds up on the surface, especially in a shady, damp spot. Grooved boards and a yearly clean help a lot.
  • Composite generally offers better slip resistance, and many ranges include a textured finish. It also doesn't splinter, which matters with children and bare feet.

In our climate, slip is worth taking seriously. Whichever material you choose, a deck that stays green and slimy is a deck that isn't getting used.

Cost

  • Softwood is the cheapest to install.
  • Hardwood sits in the middle, sometimes close to entry-level composite.
  • Composite has the highest upfront cost but the lowest ongoing cost, because there's no annual treatment to buy or arrange.

The honest way to think about it: timber costs less to build and more to maintain; composite costs more to build and almost nothing to maintain. Over the life of the deck, the totals can be closer than the initial quotes suggest.

Which suits which garden

Softwood suits a budget-conscious project or a deck that will be replaced or extended in the medium term.

Hardwood suits someone who loves the look of real timber and doesn't mind the upkeep, and wants a deck with real character that lasts.

Composite suits busy families, rental properties, anyone who wants a low-maintenance deck, and shaded or north-facing gardens where timber would turn green quickly.

Build quality matters most

The material is only half the story. A cheap composite laid on a poor frame will disappoint, and a beautiful hardwood laid without drainage will rot early. Whatever you choose, the subframe, the level, the drainage and the fixings are what determine how the deck performs over the years. See how we approach it on our decking page.

Still deciding?

If you'd like a hand weighing it up for your own garden, get in touch. We're happy to visit, look at the site and give you a straight view on which material and design would work best.

Request a quote

Questions about your own garden?

Tell us what needs doing and how to reach you. We'll talk it through with you and agree a price before anything is booked in.

Prefer to talk it through? Calling is usually quickest — especially if you're not sure which service you need.

We use your details only to reply to this enquiry. Read our privacy notice.